Toyo Open Country AT2 vs AT3: The Ultimate All-Terrain Tire Showdown

Toyo Open Country AT2 vs AT3: What’s the Difference?

The Toyo Open Country lineup has long been a favorite for truck and SUV owners who demand both durability and performance. But with the introduction of the AT3 replacing the AT2, many drivers wonder, what’s really different? This comparison of the Toyo AT2 vs AT3 breaks down the changes in design, performance, and real-world results to help the custom automotive crowd decide which tire makes sense for their build.

Understanding the Toyo Open Country Tires

The AT2 earned a reputation as a reliable all-terrain tire, offering excellent tread life and versatility. It was popular among daily drivers who occasionally hit the trails. The AT3 builds on that legacy with updated tread design, improved wet traction, and quieter highway manners. Both tires carry the Toyo Open Country badge, but their performance traits show how tire technology has evolved.

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

What Vehicles Are the Open Country AT3 Tires Commonly Fitted To?

Wondering which vehicles sport the Open Country AT3s? These tires are a top pick for trucks and SUVs that need to tackle daily commutes, weekend camping trips, and everything in between. You’ll commonly spot them on:

Full-size pickups like Silverado, Sierra, F-150, and RAM 1500
SUV heavyweights—think Tahoe, Suburban, Sequoia, and Grand Cherokee
Midsize trucks and SUVs, such as Tacoma, 4Runner, Nissan Frontier, and Xterra
Crossovers from brands like Infiniti and Lexus when off-road readiness is a must

If you drive a rig designed to haul, explore, or just look tough on the highway, chances are there’s an Open Country AT3 size that’ll fit right in. Checking the tire finder on Toyo’s site or consulting your local shop is the quickest way to confirm fitment for your specific model.

Key Differences Between the AT2 and AT3

Where the AT2 focused on longevity, the AT3 emphasizes balance. Its updated tread compound offers better grip in rain and snow while reducing road noise. The tread blocks are designed for more even wear, extending life without sacrificing traction.

In our testing, an F-150 fitted with AT2s performed admirably on dry trails but lacked bite in wet clay. The same truck on AT3s handled rain-soaked roads and off-camber climbs with more confidence. While treadwear warranty is similar (up to 65,000 miles), the AT3’s advancements in handling and comfort are noticeable on long trips.

How Does the Open Country R/T Compare to the AT3?

Curious about where the Open Country R/T fits in the line-up? Think of it as the bridge between a mud-terrain and an all-terrain tire—like the halfway point between the serious, knobby mud slingers and the versatile AT3s.

The R/T sports beefier tread blocks and larger voids than the AT3, giving it a more aggressive look and the kind of off-road capability you’ll notice on muddy trails or loose gravel. It’s designed for those who crave a bit more bite and rugged style than what the AT3 offers, but who don’t want to commit fully to the compromises of a traditional mud-terrain tire (like extra road noise and faster wear on pavement).

On pavement, the R/T is surprisingly composed, but its real strengths show on rougher terrain—handling mud better than the AT3 and digging confidently through deeper, unpacked snow. Its tread design sheds debris and chips away at the toughest off-road conditions, yet still keeps your daily drive manageable.

That said, when it comes to winter road driving, the AT3 has the edge. It boasts more tread edges and advanced siping, which translates to great grip on packed snow and icy roads. Plus, it’s stamped with the Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake symbol, signaling it’s built for severe snow service. The R/T, meanwhile, carries the M+S (Mud and Snow) rating, so it handles light snow with competence, but isn’t as specialized for true winter challenges.

In short:

AT3: Quieter, more balanced for year-round daily driving, and built for superior snow traction.
R/T: More aggressive tread for enhanced off-road and mud performance, without going full mud-terrain.

This lets you match your tire not just to your rig, but to your real-world terrain—be it city streets, snowy passes, or the unbeaten path.

Real-World User Impressions: Performance and Durability

So, how do these tires actually stack up in day-to-day use? Let’s turn to feedback from drivers who’ve put serious miles on both the AT2 and AT3.

Braking and Handling

User reviews are filled with high marks for braking and responsive handling. Drivers note confident braking in both wet and dry conditions, with praise for stable cornering—even when towing trailers or navigating winding gravel roads. Many report a marked improvement in highway stability and steering feel after making the switch from competitors like the BFG All-Terrain series.

Ride Comfort and Noise

Most agree: both the AT2 and AT3 deliver a smooth ride, handling bumps and rougher surfaces without drama. The AT3, in particular, earns kudos for its quieter highway manners, with some noting only minor road noise—often easily drowned out by the radio on longer stretches.

Road Noise: AT3 vs R/T

When it comes to highway hum, the AT3 edges out the R/T as the quieter contender. While both tires manage noise respectably—especially for aggressive all-terrain and rugged-terrain tread patterns—drivers swapping from R/Ts to AT3s often mention a noticeable drop in cabin volume. If your daily grind leans heavy on paved roads, the AT3 should offer a more subdued soundtrack, letting conversations or your favorite playlist take center stage.

Off-Road and All-Weather Performance

Gravel, snow, mud, or slick pavement—these tires get consistent accolades for their surefootedness. Rural drivers and off-road enthusiasts have found them trustworthy on everything from snowy highways to muddy two-tracks. A couple of users praised the snow traction as “effortless,” and commended the tires’ confidence-inspiring grip during heavy storms and icy commutes.

Treadwear and Durability

Longevity remains a highlight, especially for the AT2. Reports of 90,000+ miles on a set aren’t uncommon, and even more spirited drivers of the AT3 have been pleased with wear life—though the most enthusiastic off-pavement explorers noted slightly faster treadwear. Routine rotations (every 3,000 miles or so) seem to help maximize lifespan.

Fuel Efficiency

When it comes to fuel economy, reviews are generally positive. While some noted a negligible difference, others appreciated maintaining efficient mileage even with a more aggressive tread pattern.

At a Glance: User Ratings Across the Board

Braking: 5/5 (wet, dry, and snow)
Handling: 5/5 (highway and off-road)
Ride Comfort: 5/5 (smooth and quiet)
Off-Road Capability: 5/5 (dirt, gravel, snow)
Steering Responsiveness: 5/5 (confident feel)
Treadwear: 4–5/5 (excellent with regular rotation)
Fuel Efficiency: 4–5/5
Snow Traction: 4–5/5

Bottom line: for drivers racking up miles on everything from back roads to city commutes—and even taking on the occasional snowstorm—these tires have built a devoted following for their balance of comfort, control, and staying power.

Real-World Feedback: Noise, Balance, and Ride Quality

Customer reviews highlight a few key insights about the AT2 and AT3 when it comes to road noise and ride comfort. Drivers who switched to these tires often notice how quietly they cruise—even with windows up and music off, the hum is impressively subdued for an all-terrain. On highways at 70 mph and beyond, the noise levels stay pleasantly low, making for relaxed long-distance travel.

Balance and vibration are often points of concern with aggressive tread patterns, but many users report smooth rolling after installation. Some do mention chasing persistent vibrations with previous all-terrain sets, only to have those issues resolve after upgrading to the latest variants. While there are rare instances where drivers needed multiple balance sessions, most say any shake or waver at high speeds was minimal or disappeared entirely once the tires were properly mounted and broken in.

One thing that stands out across user experiences is the sense of solid construction. Owners consistently mention that both the AT2 and AT3 balance well out of the gate, with even wear showing up as long as regular rotations are kept on schedule. Notably, these tires don’t tend to develop that all-too-familiar “cold morning flat spot” vibration, which can plague other brands on chilly starts. Even at identical air pressures compared to competitors of similar load range, drivers detect a smoother, more composed ride—often describing it as a step above what they expected from a rugged all-terrain.

Feedback from rural and off-road users also points to stable, confidence-inspiring performance on gravel and backcountry roads, without excessive bouncing or shimmying at speed. Whether tackling daily commutes or winding up for a weekend adventure, the consensus is these tires deliver comfort and control where it counts.

Real-World Owner Impressions: What Drivers Are Saying

No tire review is complete without seeing how these all-terrains hold up in the wild—from gravel backroads in Idaho to snow-blown highways in New York. We scoured user reports and pulled out the themes that surfaced time and again, so you get the real story behind the tread blocks.

Highlights from Positive Reviews

Most drivers rave about the road manners of these all-terrains—especially considering their aggressive looks. Owners consistently reported:

Confident, quiet highway driving, even at 70+ mph
Impressive grip on wet pavement and snowy roads, including during those slushy morning commutes
Predictable, controlled stopping, with sturdy handling on both dry and rain-soaked surfaces
Durability that stands up to hauling trailers, tackling gravel roads, and logging serious mileage; some even claimed over 90,000 miles with minimal rotation
Easy transition from older favorites like BFGs—once plagued by balancing woes, drivers found smoother, trouble-free rides after switching

Common Complaints and Issues

On the flip side, a handful of users flagged a few repeat issues:

Persistent vibration at speeds above 60 mph, even after multiple balancing attempts
Some drivers found that, despite careful maintenance, tread life fell a bit short for those who tend to drive “spiritedly” or favor rough surfaces
Noticeable road noise at highway speeds; more pronounced than some rivals, though many say it fades with the radio on
Availability can be hit-or-miss, depending on your local dealer

Overall, real-world feedback confirms these tires are a dependable choice for mixed driving—highways, snow, gravel, and the occasional muddy rut. They’ve even convinced a few long-time BFG diehards to make the switch for smoother rides and better traction.

How Tire Rotation and Maintenance Affect Longevity

Routine maintenance can make or break the life you get out of your all-terrains. Rotating your tires at regular intervals (typically every 5,000 to 7,000 miles) helps ward off uneven tread wear—especially important if you put your rig through a mix of local highways, gravel roads, and towing duties. Even with just basic attention, these tires show impressive stamina, easily outpacing some competitors well past the 50,000-mile mark.

Alignments matter, but the robust design of these tires means some owners have seen stellar results even without frequent adjustments. If you’re the type who chases dusty two-tracks or tows a camper on weekends, diligent rotation will keep your traction and handling dialed in while extending life. Skipping these steps? Expect performance and longevity to taper off, especially under heavier loads or off-road adventures.

Enthusiasts who stick to a rotation and keep an eye on pressures often report tread life numbers that put well-known brands like BFGoodrich to the test. Bottom line: Regular care means you’ll benefit from both the ruggedness and the long haul comfort these tires are known for.

AT2 vs AT3: Which Is Right for You?

If you want a budget-friendly option with proven durability, the AT2 is still a solid choice when available. But for most buyers, the AT3 represents the future. It’s engineered to handle daily commutes, long overland routes, and off-road adventures without compromise. For Jeep and truck enthusiasts who build rigs for mixed use, the AT3 checks more boxes.

Conclusion

The Toyo Open Country AT2 was a trusted tire for years, but the AT3 improves on its formula with better wet traction, comfort, and handling while maintaining durability. For most Jeep and truck owners in the custom automotive scene, the AT3 is the smarter investment. When choosing between the two, it comes down to this: if you can find the AT2 at a discount, it’s still a strong option, but the AT3 is the future of all-terrain performance.

FAQs About Toyo Open Country Tires

Across more than 270 reviews from enthusiasts (think Tread readers, Jeep owners, and the occasional F-150 driver), the overall rating lands at a respectable 3.8 out of 5 stars.

Q1. What’s the main difference between Toyo Open Country AT2 and AT3?

A: The AT3 has an updated tread compound and design for better wet traction, quieter ride quality, and improved handling, while the AT2 focused primarily on long tread life.

Q2. Are Toyo Open Country tires good for off-roading?

A: Yes. Both AT2 and AT3 models are capable off-road. The AT3 performs better in mixed conditions like mud, rain, and light snow.

Q3. Which Toyo Open Country tire lasts longer?

A: Both AT2 and AT3 carry up to a 65,000-mile warranty, but the AT3 is designed for more even wear, meaning it may maintain performance longer.

Q4. What do the Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake (3PMSF) and M+S ratings mean for winter driving?

A: Here’s the quick rundown. The 3PMSF symbol—Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake—means a tire is certified for serious winter traction. It’s a stamp of approval that the tire meets higher industry standards for acceleration and grip in severe snow, thanks to special tread patterns and rubber compounds designed for cold temps.

On the other hand, the M+S (Mud & Snow) rating is a more basic classification. It indicates the tread can handle mud and light snow, but it’s not the same as being engineered specifically for harsh winter conditions. So if you often tackle wintry roads or venture into colder climates, look for that 3PMSF symbol. It’s your best bet for safer, more confident winter driving.

How Does Toyo Stack Up Against BFG and Michelin?

Based on customer feedback, Toyo Open Country tires often impress those coming from other top brands like BFGoodrich (BFG) and Michelin. Drivers who previously relied on BFG for their all-terrain needs sometimes switched after running into issues with balancing or inconsistent ride quality, and many report a noticeably smoother and quieter experience with Toyo tires right out of the gate.

When compared to Michelin, a brand widely respected for highway comfort and long tread life, the Toyos tend to hold their own—especially for drivers who want a balance between daily driving manners and trail capability. Many owners point out that Toyos feel “sticky” and confidence-inspiring in wet and dry conditions, matching up well to Michelin’s reputation while often delivering better off-road traction.

A recurring theme in customer stories is trust in local expert recommendations. When veteran enthusiasts and shop staff are rolling on Toyos themselves, that adds a layer of confidence. For those who put thousands of miles on their trucks or even hand them down to family, the switch often feels like an upgrade. In short, if you’ve tried BFG or Michelin and want a quieter, more versatile all-terrain option, Toyo’s AT lineup frequently earns high marks for satisfaction and all-around value.

Q4. What do different tire ply ratings (C, D, E, F) mean?

A: Ply ratings on tires (such as C, D, E, and F) indicate their load-carrying strength, not the actual number of plies inside the tire. Here’s a quick breakdown:

C (6-ply rating): Suited for lighter loads—commonly found on smaller trucks, SUVs, and vans that see occasional hauling or off-road use.
D (8-ply rating): Built to handle heavier loads than C-rated tires—ideal for midsize to heavy-duty pickups towing moderate trailers or hauling gear.
E (10-ply rating): Designed for serious work—chosen by drivers who tow heavy trailers or frequently load up their truck or SUV for overlanding.
F (12-ply rating): The heavyweight option, usually reserved for commercial applications, heavy trailers, or rigs that need maximum load support.

Choosing the right ply rating depends on your vehicle’s load requirements, how you use it, and your adventures—whether it’s a weekend trip or towing a camper cross-country.

Read More: